itsxolo, outside of nisemonogatari every monogatari release commie made was translated from scratch and had an original script
this is because crunchyroll (again, outside of nise) has always had objectively terrible monogatari subs
I don't mean to say that commie has never done an original """translation""", but as far as I can tell, nobody left in the group knows Japanese, so the only """translations""" they do now are when they can cringify an official script. Correct me if I'm wrong.
>Correct me if I’m wrong.
[a sample timestamped for your pleasure.](https://i.imgur.com/USWMdK8.png)
and that's ignoring the obvious part of how a translator in the group translates songs when we just edit a simulcast.
tbh herkz i think both koyo and owari 2 have a mostly competent retail script. owari 2 script is actually quite good if you fix the poor line breaks and few stupid mistakes. honestly i dont see why it would take you guys more than a couple months to present a good sub for both of these with R1 as base.
and also koyo is barely more than an extra. even retail subs are sufficient imo. no need to waste much time on that. and i mostly liked what commie did with monogatari fwiw...
Comments - 21
murt
Maxine
rosanjo9
ItsXolo
Mugi
herkz
Akiyuki_Shimbo
SomaHeir
ap1234
herkz
ItsXolo
jymmy
Astral
men_douk_sai
herkz
tai0909
Akiyuki_Shimbo
SnowyNix
andryzoun
watashi666
surume